Monday, January 6, 2014

Fact or Fiction.

PSA says:
Thank you Lee . Actions speak louder then words.
Justin running away from Trista,reporters and his lawyer on his court date for assault.
Justin assaulting Courtney then saying,,normal night, one foot in front of the other.
Justin telling people they didn’t drink in the house (basement full of empty beer bottles.
Justin not wanting to talk to a reporter ( another missed chance to speak for Ayla ) and telling them to ” Eat s#$t.”
Justin acting strange the day he had a visitor before Ayla was reported missing
Justin hiding in the bathroom after calling 911.
Justins action since ,” Drinking beer and chasing women ” from his own mouth.
Justin not co-operating in a fatherly was to a mother whose child is missing on his watch.
Im sure there is so much more in his actions that proves he is an uncaring human being.



This is a comment from U4A's recent post Actions Speak Louder Than Words Justin


Let me just touch on these. One by one.

1. Justin running away from Trista, reporters and his lawyer... How does this make him "uncaring"... It shows that he didn't want to be badgered in public, harassed and asked repetitive questions by Trista that, in private, he has answered time and time again. You don't like his answers? I'm sorry, but that doesn't make him a terrible person.

2. Justin assaulting Courtney... Thrown out of court. Charges dropped. End of story.

3. Who cares if people ever really drank in Justin's home. We drink in my home. Occasionally.  A six pack of beer could last me 2 months, but we do drink here. So did my parents. Adults are allowed to have a drink. It's legal. And, Basement full of beer bottles "HANSON: Well, let me tell you what I left out of the case -- actually, let me respond to what the previous caller -- I didn`t get the name -- they say police had stated publicly that a kidnapping did not take place. So, that rules out Trista, period.

And what -- in answer to your question, I left out -- what I left out, when I was putting it together, was one of the statements that the investigators said to Trista when they showed her this evidence was the (INAUDIBLE) that was littered with beer bottles. One of the detectives commented the house -- it looked like a hoarder`s house." - Speculation. Comes from Jeff and Trista. Not an "official statement". And don't try the "they didn't say she was lieing" bullshit. She's lied before, and they haven't refuted her statements. They say they will not back her up - those are her words.

4. Justin telling a reporter to eat shit... really? Where? Was that the entire conversation? Did they say something to provoke an "eat shit" comment? Because I bet if Trista was provoked she may say the same thing. Situational.

5. Justin acting strange the day before Ayla went missing - Second hand, hearsay, speculation. So someone else says this, yet friends close to him say he was normal. You believe what you believe, others will believe what they want. Still not a valid fact or point.

6. Justin "hiding in the bathroom" - again, speculation. From Trista, to Chelsea Hoffman....sigh.

7. Justin's actions since... seriously, from his own mouth, yet said second or third hand... again, hearsay, speculation, and I hardly believe any truth from it.

8. Justin not cooperating with Trista is what I'm assuming this comment means. Again, malarkey. We have seen selected text messages. We know there was a strong line of communication. And I know first hand that Justin tried to communicate and cooperate with Trista in the beginning. Do you blame him for pulling away when the "baby killer" and "he murdered my daughter" comments began? If he was outwardly blaming Trista of those things, do you believe she would have pulled away and tried to avoid him? If he was harassing her, do you believe that things wouldn't have gone the same way by the opposite person?


We need to all look at this picture as a whole. Whether we want to admit it or not, Ayla has two parents, a mother and a father. They each had a role in her upbringing, I don't care how small or large. Yes, Trista had Ayla for most of her life, but Justin was playing a role in helping Trista through her tough time (which, if you're not judgemental and see it for simply what it is, it's a man, helping the mother of his child, because she really truly needs it.) No matter what story you stick with, what you believe, there were two parents and there are two parents suffering from Ayla's absence. Whether you know Justin, you know Trista, or you just saw this case on the news and became attached, the most important thing is to bring answers the RIGHT WAY, without defaming and harassing and ruining someones life who may not deserve it.

150 comments:

  1. I highly doubt that Justin is suffering. In fact, he's probably enjoying the "control" over the situation and helping to cause Trista to suffer wondering. I've seen enough information to come to the (very) logical conclusion that Justin knows what happened to Ayla and where she is hidden. People can bury their head in the sand, but there are too many truths lined up on the side of Justin knows, if one cares enough to notice.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie as far as #3, the difference in your case and Justin's is, you just stated that you occasionally drink in your home. I don't know if the issue is that there was drinking in the home or that they lied and tried to hide it. Granted LE hasn't confirmed there were beer bottles in the basement but if true, why lie about? If true, why have their attorney lie about it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't recall Justin ever saying that they did not drink in the house. Phoebe's and Elisha's lawyer did make that announcement. Perhaps he meant for people only to believe it of PD and ED, I don't know. Certainly both Lance and Justin are known on social sites by friends as "party boys".

      I get squeamish when people attribute quotes to the wrong person. I get the same feeling when posters, who obviously dislike Justin, tell stories about Justin and they are believed as Gospel when no one can prove the truth of everything said about him.. And that goes for the posts about Trista, too, from people who obviously dislike her intensely...some who don't even profess to know her.

      .Anything said from an online "local" poster about Phoebe and Elisha should be taken with a grain of salt, too. The statements about any of these people could be interesting, but not true. True or not, we likely will never know anything more than we do right now about this case. What was true, what was false will remain a mystery. Sad but true.

      Am I defending Justin, Phoebe and Elisha? Not at all. To me their behavior alone speaks of deceit to cover up Ayla's death in that house. Innocent people do not act the way they have acted. And it is too much of a coincidence for me to believe that Ayla was horribly hurt without her being taken for medical care, and then she was mysteriously taken by a midnight intruder.. Especially when Justin seems to have no intention of explaining why Ayla's blood was discovered in certain patterns in his bedroom. Nor has he ever indicated the slightest worry about his child in captivity.

      I believe what happened to Ayla was an accident that the people in the house thought would not be believed as one. Why they thought that is another mystery...maybe dating back to Ayla's broken arm.

      Anyway, I tend not to believe anything posted about the lives of anybody involved. All the people involved seem to either acquit or indict themselves by their own words, and actions.

      Delete
  3. Katie, thank you for writing. What do the Dipietros say happened to Ayla?
    Why do they not tell the police all they know?
    Why do the Trudelas back this up when it hurts their business and lives?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anon, thank you for your questions.

      The Dipietros contend Ayla was kidnapped/taken in the night from their home. Their story has not changed. They, in their minds, have told MSP all the know.

      The Tudela's back this up because they have known them a long time, and believe that what they have said is the truth. As do I.

      Delete
    2. Katie, what do the DiPietros say about Ayla's blood "evidence"? Do they tell you how Ayla was hurt...if she was hurt?

      Delete
    3. The Tudela's back up the Dipietro "story" because they have known them for a long time? Gosh, I cannot tell you how many neighbors of murderers have done that.

      I don't care how long someone has known someone, that does not mean the people can't do horrendous things. You never know anyone that well. None of us can count how many times we've witnessed someone say, "my friend couldn't possibly have done that","oh those people are so kind there is no way they could have done that", etc. etc.

      Unless the Tudelas were in the house when Ayla went "missing" they know nothing about their "friends" or what they could or couldn't have done. They may well believe their lies because they have known them a long time, but that doesn't make the lies the truth. It just makes the Tudela's gullible.

      Delete
  4. They need to explain how that blood got there before Ayla was kidnapped. Ayla would have been crying and screaming, there is absolutely no way anyone slept through that!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WHAT BLOOD? What the hell are you talking about? You do not know what blood evidence has been found. None of us do. Nobody calls someone a murderer over what a person states they were shown! Use your brain.

      Delete
    2. ^what Anon 10:47 said.
      It's time for the Trista lovers to own up to their love of all things Trista over their love for Ayla. You only believe what she says. You call Justin a druggy, when we have solid proof that Trista was the druggy. But that's okay, right? Because it's Trista.

      It doesn't matter that she admits she was under the influence while supposedly caring for her kids. AYLA WAS TAKEN ON JUSTIN'S WATCH, so obviously she gets excused for everything she's done wrong, even lying and contradicting herself in almost every interview she's given.

      No, that's okay; it's Trista the Goddess Who Can Never Do Anything Wrong. Get a clue!

      Delete
    3. And if you don't bow down and kiss Trista's feet and hold on to every word she says as absolute truth, you obviously are a Justin supporter. Hey, guess what? I ONLY CARE ABOUT AYLA! I think BOTH Trista and Justin fucked up and made some seriously bad choices in parenting Ayla. Just because I don't worship the ground Trista walks on does not mean I think Justin can do or has done no wrong.

      Delete
  5. LE confirmed Ayla's blood was found in the house.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes they did. And if they came to your house and you had young children know this - they would find blood. Does that make you a murderer?

      Delete
    2. Yes, they said some blood was found in the basement. Not once did they say it was a bloodbath like Trista claims.

      Delete
    3. Yes. They confirmed her blood was in the home. But they did not confirm the age or amount of the blood. All accounts of where or how much come from Trista via Jeff. Ergo third hand supposedly from LE. At that point I draw the line.

      Ever had a bloody nose? Or a toddler with one who thinks blowing without a tissue is reasonable? I'll make sure my husband takes pictures next time my children do. You'd be amazed at the ways children shed blood and the patterns it makes depending on the injury, most small and bandaid worthy. Some not even needing a bandaid.

      Delete
    4. Katie, there you go, being all logical again. We're supposed to be the simple minded ones who follow Justin's every whim and don't think for ourselves. I'm so glad you're here to guide us and tell us what to believe.

      No, but seriously.. I wish that Trista's followers could look at this case objectively for once and realize that they are the ones being manipulated and played. I suppose that's not an easy thing to see or admit to though.

      Delete
    5. Oh wait Katie I want to hear the fan story again. . . that was the best. Maybe that is what happened to poor baby Ayla. As you stated in your long ago post . . . accidents happen right. Your parenting skills sicken me and if that is anything close to what Ayla had for supervision I just don't even want to think about it. And you are the one that calls yourself a medical professional???

      Delete
    6. While you're waiting for the fan story again, why don't you ask Trista about what DHHS thinks of HER current parenting skills?

      Delete
    7. Anon 352: next time I am stuck between a rock and hard place like that, I'll be sure I leave my children in a room in 90+ degree weather with no air circulating. And when they die of heat exhaustion in their sleep I will make sure I tell msp it was your idea and you told me it was better parenting. Okay? :)

      Delete
    8. Oh look. It's Dot Space again. We never tire of your judgmental attitude amd Trista worshipping ways. Quick, I see a candle going out! You better go make that amazing sacrifice for Ayla by clicking your mouse to keep it lit!!!

      Delete
    9. Keep defending the Dipietros, they need all the defending they can get because sooner or later the truth will come out and AYLA will get the justice she deserves. Katie what the Dipietros tell you the blood came from not matter how old it was it couldn't be too old because Ayla hadn't been there that long, even if it wasn't a lot I know if my child bled I would know it. There has to be an explanation, how come we haven't gotten one from them. . . you know why Katie, because they are hiding something! Trust me I will be very weary of any medical professional that I come across whose name is Katie!

      Delete
    10. Does a nosebleed splatter blood on the walls? Just asking. Does the bleeder have to be hooked on a nail on the wall?

      Delete
    11. All we can do is guess how the blood came about because the W4 are keeping their mouths shut. If it was a nose bleed I think they would have come forward real fast with this excuse. instead we have nothing. No wonder everyone thinks they are guilty of something. What do they expect, for people to believe that a kidnapper came in just for Ayla and no one else in the neighborhood should be worried about their children, Elisha should't be worried about her child. Common sense would tell you that they aren't worried about a kidnapper, they aren't worried about anyone finding Ayla, they made sure of that. If there was truly a kidnapper in the area don't you think the police would have warned neighbors? Common sense people. Katie its obvious that you will believe in W4's words (or lack of) until the truth comes out. I have no doubt the truth won't being coming from any of them, but I do believe the truth will come out. And I have no doubt from your words that even if they are guilty of neglect you will stand by them, after all you pretty much live by the same parenting skills! If it was 90 degrees in that child's room you should have still made sure that the "fan" was in a place that would keep "your child" out of danger. How old were you anyway?

      Delete
    12. Did you ever read the original post? The fan was in a corner of their room, facing a wall, simply for air movement. How it became turned around and how my son walked into it are still a mystery to me. He doesn't remember. We weren't in the room. I'm really REALLY glad there are so many perfect parents posting anonymously on websites, because here I thought we all made simple mistakes. If my son was seriously hurt from this incident, I would not call it a simple mistake.

      I also wish you would take a look back at my previous words. I've said that if turns out a large group of people have lied to my face repeatedly for years now, I would not stand by them, I would not stand by anyone. I have also said that while I do know Justin and family, and Derek and Heidi and family, I am here for AYLA and I am here for having BOTH SIDES be looked at equally. Trista is not innocent in this either. But I don't think either of them should be dragged through mud when their child is missing. If it turns out that Justin did do something, or someone in the house did do something, then by all means, please, drag them through the mud to find out why, when, what and how it happened. Same goes for anyone else. But until then, this all needs to be looked at objectively, as if no one has a dog in the fight, so to say.

      Delete
    13. "Trista is not innocent in this either" That just goes to show how ignorant you are "Katie", Justin had Ayla in his care at the time of the "kidnapping". Are you saying Trista has fault in it because she went to seek help and trusted the father of her baby to care for her? thats like saying someone who suffers domestic abuse is guilty for saying the wrong thing. JMO Sure its not yours, you and i don't think alike at all. As far as the fan being turned around against a wall, does that even sound smart to you? I don't get it.

      Delete
    14. Furthermore, and this is fact, the Dips were concerned about Ayla being taken, why on earth would they go to bed without making sure the doors and windows were locked. Why would they not take precautions to protect her. Why would he put her to bed alone and sleep with his GF and her son downstairs. If you can make this make sense to me I would appreciate it. People just don't act that way. But then again, I don't believe you will find too many parents that would leave a running fan in a babies bedroom unattended, especially one without a front on it. SMH

      Delete
    15. Katie, Now all of the sudden ur saying the fan was turned towards the wall? If your going to lie, think it through and make sure it at least makes sense!! What good do you think a fan would do if it was turned against the wall?None! And now you say that the child turned the fan around without getting hurt but then walked into it? If you would lie about this then what else are you lying about?

      Delete
    16. Anon, thank you for now clarifying you never read the first post. It was originally stated the fan was facing the wall, purely in the room for AIR MOVEMENT. That was in the original post, and it is in ever comment I've made about it since. Please, take your bullshit elsewhere.

      Delete
    17. If I read the post wrong I apologize. I was going to look for and reread the post but its not important. Ayla is

      Delete
  6. http://www.kjonline.com/news/Blood-found-at-missing-toddlers-home-is-Ayla-Reynolds.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ayla is still considered "MISSING" and Trista has not been ruled out as a suspect.

      Delete
    2. LE has said she is likely dead. They said the 3 in the house know more than they are telling.

      Delete
    3. And where do they say - anyone in that house murdered her or abused her ? Everyone has jumped to conclusions without evidence or facts. Let them do their job. It's not for YOU or ME to judge who is guilty and who is innocent.

      Delete
    4. How come no one worries about Ayla with her abductor? Oh, yeah, because she is with Trista or a relative of the Reynolds, right? We don't have to worry about how the one we're all here for is faring. She's just fine...with a change of address is all..Enjoying her third Christmas with cuddly toys. Justin is not worried about her.

      Delete
    5. " Investigators have ruled out any possibility that Ayla left the house on her own or that she was abducted. Investigators discovered Ayla's blood in the basement of her home, and the three adults who were in the home at the time are withholding information. Police believe that Ayla is probably dead."

      When the State Police posted the above words on their website, it's pretty clear there much have been enough of Ayla's blood found for them to state, "they believe that Ayla is probably dead".

      Keep burying your head in the sand Justin supporters and argue about how they didn't say 'how much' blood. Whatever it takes for you to feel warm and fuzzy about Justin. Fact is, the police know something happened to Ayla in the Dipietro home. That much is clear in their own statement. Justin knows too, he just isn't talking.

      Delete
    6. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  7. http://www.cnn.com/2012/01/29/justice/maine-missing-toddler/index.html

    ReplyDelete
  8. Has anyone else heard about the event planned in Waterville later this month? Anonymous plans to demonstrate at the Waterville Police Department to demand an arrest of Justin and the others.

    From what I've always understood about the group Anonymous, they care about upholding the Constitution, due process, and squelching governmental tyranny. Yet they want to take away Justin's rights based solely on the shit that Trista and Ron have spewed since the beginning, before police said they suspected foul play?

    I used to respect Anonymous' stance on things, but not any more. Asshats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That group does not represent Ayla. The maternal family has not approved of the group Anonymous. The agreement was for a peaceful protest. They have no business associating Ayla's name with their hate and prejudice.

      Delete
    2. I don't understand the purpose. Waterville PD is not the lead agency in this case. What issue does this group have with them?

      Delete
    3. I agree. Their posters are effing creepy as hell, too! No one in their right mind should want sweet Ayla's face alongside that shit.

      Delete
  9. That is true that the police has not confirmed anything Trista said. But they have made several comments "Nobody would put themselves in Trista's shoes" The 3 who were in the house are not telling everything they know" "It is highly unlikely that Ayla will be found alive" We have no criticism of what Trista said. The Reynolds have been very cooperative. Plus the countless searches in woods or in the water. I has become hard to believe that what Trista said is all lies, and that Justin is a victim. But I still don't think that we should blame all the ones who believe in him, or even his family. He may be a very persuasive or manipulative person. They appear to really believe in his innocence. It's hard for a person's close circle to see the person for what they are and not to be blinded.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Justin is an adolescent. He lets women do for him and speak for him. Some women get a kick from a dependent male. Many women like "bad boys". Justin attracts them like Ronald Cummings attracted them online when his daughter "disappeared".

      Ronald and Justin are two of a kind. The women who fawn over them and defend them are interesting in themselves.

      Delete
    2. You dont have to be on anyone's "side" to want justice for Ayla. I thought it was wrong when Trista was called names and amongst them she was also called a "murderer "- until the "blood evidence" was released. I think its wrong to call Justin and family names also.

      Both sides of these familys have made mistakes with drugs and alcohol so to put down one for it you really are condeming both.

      For people to come out and say - I'm doing more for Ayla then you are - is childish. Not everyone is out there needing praise for what they do for Ayla. And you may not see what they have done or ever know about it. Were all here for Ayla. Thats enough in itself. Dont make it a contest.

      The bottom line is no matter who is guility - that is for law to decide - not any vigil anti groups or hate mongerers. Its wrong to stir up hate against anyone, especially when they have not been judged in a court of law.

      How does one light a candle and pray but in the same day state hate and hurtfullness towards another humban being?

      I've said stupid things i wish i could take back. We all get caught up in the moment. And for that I apologize. I can be humble and i can admit i have been wrong on numerous occasions. That being said this is a new year, I am going to work on that.

      Bonnie your right - the police have released statements that put Justin in a bad light. But it does not give us the right to judge him to condem him and to harrass him and spout words of hate towards him and his family.

      If Justin/family are guilty he will receive justice, but not by anyones hands but the law. If they are innocecent ? How can you take bad your words of hate? That worked both ways I agree people have done the same to Trista.


      Jumping off my pedestal ... We would have been more helpful to Ayla working as a team rather than the way it is now. I wish it could have been different ... for Ayla's sake

      Delete
  10. Katie says...."...next time I am stuck between a rock and hard place like that, I'll be sure I leave my children in a room in 90+ degree weather with no air circulating"

    One could move the children into another room that is cooler, kids usually love "camping out" anywhere in the house.

    Yes, we all have made stupid mistakes.

    Justin stated, "Eat shit" to a reporter during a phone call, The reporter asked for an interview telling Justin HE could pick the questions and the interview could be anywhere, anytime Justin chose. Justin had only a two word response, "Eat shit"
    Believe it or not, but I know it happened, without provocation.
    I do not know however, how many interviews he turned down nor why, if he did so but I would guess he was asked more times than he accepted.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Please move on about the fan - Trista could have stopped drinking and drugging but it didnt happen it was a stupid mistake. get it? Its over and done with at this point.

      I dont care that Justin told a reporter to eat shit.

      Stick to whats important. Finding Ayla - not the same stupid shit over and over. Lets move on people

      Delete
    2. The. "Eat Shit" comment is part of this main post, I assume it is okay to comment on parts contained in this post?

      Delete
    3. Then you also must be horrified that Trista was so irresponsible to get herself into a situation that she would have to leave Ayla with her father.She had to know he was no good, and with the injuries she witnessed Ayla coming home with what could she have been thinking. How could anyone have been so reckless, according to some it did cost Ayla her life.You will never be able to move on from this for sure.

      Delete
    4. The fan incident is far worse then what Trista did. Trista had an addition, it is a disease, *Katie* was working on ignorance!

      Delete
    5. The only person responsible for whatever happened to Ayla is Justin as it was his responsibility to make sure she was safe. He didn't do that even though he worried someone was going to come and take her, he didn't even have the sense to make sure doors and windows were locked. He actually put her upstairs in a room by herself while he, his gf and her son cuddled downstairs. What is up with that. What caused Ayla's blood to be all over the house and on Justin? An answer to this question would give us the answer as to what happened to poor Ayla that night. Justin is a woman beater, not too far from a child abuser if you ask me.

      Delete
    6. Drugs only prove Trista's ignorance and look at the rest of her family all losers. Apples don't fall far from the tree in that bunch. Fan accident far worse ask Trista I think she would disagree.

      Delete
    7. @ AnonymousJanuary 10, 2014 at 1:21 PM
      The thing is parents take equal responsibility for their children and what happens to them. If one parent is abusing the child and the other parent doesn't stop them, then they are enabling the other parent by taking no action.

      Delete
  11. You clarified it. Thank you. Now can we move forward.

    ReplyDelete
  12. OT: I've been trying all day to post on U4A and can't get through. My comments won't post. Yes, I raised some unpopular questions over there yesterday, but MM said she welcomed my input. It appears she has now had a change of heart. I see the "regulars" can still post, but I can't. Nothing like keeping it "open for civil discussion" eh, MM?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can't get in there either!

      Delete
    2. I took a break from moderating last night and when I got back online, U4A was down. I haven't blocked anyone or put anyone in moderation. There are no comments waiting in moderation and only about 10 comments have been made since midnight last night. I don't know what the problem is. More than one person hasn't been able to comment so something is wrong. I'm sorry.

      Delete
    3. Thank you for the explanation, MM. I figured it had to be a computer glitch (not unexpected considering the cold temps!). But I still can't post. So I'll pose my vexing questions here. Is U4A affiliated with the group Anonymous? Jeff gave mixed messages on that matter. Also, I don't believe in spreading rumors. So I just want it confirmed that Alex and Melissa Fazzi were present at that meeting. I have it on good authority that they were not. I certainly understand that you cannot speak for Jeff, but these are pretty basic questions that I am posing.

      Delete
    4. Well, this is awkward, MM. I STILL can't post on U4A. So I need to use this blog as a temporary portal to communicate. I'm trying to understand your position of posting addie's comments. Why did you allow addie's comment containing Phoebe's email to remain on U4A? And continue to do so? Why did you allow addie to introduce the group Anonymous to U4A? Why did you allow addie's comment that Elisha goes to Discovery House every day in a state-funded taxi for a methadone fix without asking questions?

      Delete
  13. Question for Jeff. You still maintain Alex and Melissa Fazzi were present at the January 3 meeting, right? I have your word on that, right?

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'll assume this is just a computer glitch that will be rectified and nothing more sinister. But I don't understand how some can post and I no longer can. Very odd.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe it's because you are paranoid? Or think you, above all, should be exempt from what happenes to many others during a tech or weather glitch. Get a grip! Stop acting like a whiney child!

      Delete
    2. I couldn't post over "there" yesterday or today. I post all the time. Now, I get a message "Can't open socket" -- whatever that means. I don't think Meanie Mountain Mama is up to any dirty tricks just becaise some people have differeing opinions..

      Delete
    3. Lets just hope its an updating issue and not hacking or spamming because that would be wrong, at least some of us think so.

      Delete
  15. Here's a fascinating read! http://www.allvoices.com/contributed-news/16302360-ayla-reynolds-update-protest-for-justice

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't understand. I thought the idea behind the Press for Prosecution was to put pressure on the AG to take this case to a grand jury. The online petition is addressed to Janet Mills. The Case for Ayla spells out that the intent was to press the AG to act. Why on earth would the family join a protest against the Waterville PD? What have they done other than work to find Ayla?

      Delete
    2. Oh please.... Of course this is not about protesting the Waterville Police Dept.
      This isn't about prosecution, it's about persecution.
      Poor Ayla, I just can not believe the disrespect ............,.

      Delete
    3. "Poor Ayla, I just can not believe the disrespect ..........." Neither can I A1. Justin has so badly disrespected Ayla and let's pray justice prevails.

      Delete
    4. I agree Anon 7:50 PM. No one has disrespected Ayla the way Justin and his family have disrespected her. I pray justice prevails. When it does, I want to hear the Justin sympathizers have to say then.

      Delete
  16. Jeff, do you really think Chelsea is an appropriate media source to report on Ayla?
    http://catrionaiscrazy.com/2013/11/18/chelsea-hoffman-heartless-troll-masquerading-as-journalist/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am sure he does, they are on the same level imo. Neither one has any class or credibility. I believe most of the lies Trista has been caught in were told to her by Jeff.

      Delete
    2. WOW! And you think you have class????Disgusting! Dispicable! Is this Phoebe or one of her followers!

      Delete
    3. Never said I had any class just tell it like I see it.

      Delete
    4. It definately shows!

      Delete
  17. WOW! Thanks for the link anon 12:25.

    ReplyDelete
  18. WOW MM and Lee finally have an opinion on the protest! Well, whatever you call it.

    MM's so funny! Only commenters using captcha can't post. CG can post on her own. Why is MM posting everybody's comments? Silly woman.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CG uses captcha too silly anon.

      Delete
  19. Hey, "Tomato Soup" your soup is a little thin. Can see right through you.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Why cant people act like adults and not bad mouth people with different throughts. I feel bad for Ayla and feel she need justice. I can not understand why they protesting at Waterville police station when the state police is the one doing investigation it does not make a lot since other then that is were ayla disappeared from. I just wish they would find her. cag

    ReplyDelete
  21. “At this point, we believe that foul play has occurred in connection with Ayla’s disappearance,” Massey said in a written release. “We base our conclusions on evidence gathered by investigators during the past two weeks. This case has evolved from the search for a missing child to a criminal investigation.”

    ReplyDelete
  22. Of course there is "foul play" Ayla is missing! Nobody gave her away she was taken! That's a crime isn't it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The last time I checked it was.

      Delete
    2. If Ayla was truly "taken", why don't the DiPietros and friends show any worry, and anxiety about Ayla with her captor? Some one has her. Evidently someone criminal. That is, unless the Justin and family know exactly where she is and are content to leave well enough alone.

      Why are the three in the house withholding information about the "taken"? What about their combined or separate stories of that night show LE that they are not" telling all they know" about that night?

      Nobody believes in the blood evidence among those posting for Justin and Family here, but in heaven's name why would anyone not tell the the whole truth if your child is "taken"? Parents with "taken" children care nothing about themselves because their focus is not on themnselves. They care about fiding their child, or at least keeping her name before the public so that she will not be forgotten.

      Why aren't the DiPietros and their friends banding together, hiring a P.I., moving heaven and earth to rescue Ayla since she has been " taken"? They have always been more involved in defending themselves than taking any action to retrieve Ayla from the hands of, who is it? Trista and her relatives? DiPietro relatives. A criminal pervert?

      LE has said that Ayla did not wander off by herself, and THERE WAS NO ABDUCTION, and the three in the house that night are "not telling all they know". (.I can find several quotes to support this, if need be.)

      What is left? Ayla didn't wander away, nobody took her. What's the answer?

      Delete
  23. Since you dont live with the DiPietros I'm going to have to say you have no idea what they do, have done , or are currently doing. Again just people jumping to conclusions because they dont know what they are talking about. Guessing.. and always guessing the worst.
    Maybe they are doing things that dont get the "Publics" attention. I dont know, I dont live with them, I dont know how they feel, or what they do for Ayla. And neither do you.
    Just because you have no idea.. dont make shit up.
    LE doesnt appear to know what happened to Ayla. They can guess just like you can. But the fact is they have no idea what happened to Ayla and neither do you.
    Stop talking like you have all the answers when LE doesnt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Maybe they are doing things that dont get the "Publics" attention. I dont know, I dont live with them, I dont know how they feel, or what they do for Ayla. And neither do you."

      Then we're even! Neither of has the inside track. neither has a clue! I can ask questions even when you get nasty and bury your head in the sand.

      What have I made up? LE has given some answers. You just choose to ignore them.

      And as far as I am concerned, I am only comparing the DiPietros to how other parents, later found to be innocent, acted and re-acted when their children went missing. The DiPietros don't fit that mold of innocent, IMO.And
      evidently not in the MSP's opinion, either.

      Delete
    2. It is not a fact that LE has no idea what happened to Ayla.

      LE has stated they believe she is deceased, her blood is in DiPietro's house, the people in that house aren't telling what they know, she was not kidnapped, she did not leave house on own, she was victim of foul play. It sounds to me like LE does have more than an idea what happened to her and the fact that they went to a grand jury shortly after she was reported missing indicates they have more than a vague idea what happened to Ayla.

      Delete
    3. They "believe" is an opinion, not a fact. I'm not arguing it looks suspicious, I'm arguing nobody knows what happened to Ayla but Ayla and whoever took her.

      It could have been someone from that house that walked out with Ayla. I'm saying you have no right to condem anyone until they have been found guilty in a court of law. Nobody has even been charged with anything to this day.

      Its suspicious but it doesn't mean everyone in that household is guilty of a crime. And if they are that's for LE to sort out. Not a bunch of torch lighters. He's not Frankenstein he's a human being whom we don't know if he himself is guilty or not.

      I'm not saying anyone of them are innocent, the fact is NOBODY KNOWS who is guilty.

      Some are treating the whole family as if they are all guilty. That's wrong. You don't need even a smidgen of common sense to know that.

      Delete
    4. Anon 10:20...thank you for your reasonable and sane comment.

      Delete
    5. Believe,, To accept or regard as true.
      Opinion....A belief, judgment , or way of thinking.
      Belief implies often deliberate acceptance and intellectual assent.

      Delete
    6. MSP has said that "We believe it is" highly unlikely" that Ayla Reynolds will be " found" alive.

      ...MSP makes the "judgment", that Ayla probably will not be "found" alive.

      From their website...Police "believe" that Ayla is "probably" dead.

      Probably....Almost certain, as far as one can tell.

      Nowhere, at no time, has MSP ever said that Ayla is dead. Never.

      That ells me that they do not know if she is or not.

      If Ayla was kidnapped, I "believe" it is highly unlikely that she'll be found alive.

      I can't pronounce anyone guilty of anything until I know what happened to Ayla.

      Delete
    7. No one can say that a person is 100 percent dead without finding a body. They form their belief on the evidence that they found.

      Delete
    8. I agree that judging the whole family is wrong, and I personally don't believe they know. But it has become very hard to believe that Justin doesn't know. If the description of the blood by Trista is accurate and true, Justin knows, it is in his very bedroom, and it's too much to be from a simple cut in the foot.

      Delete
    9. It's impossible to be anything but 100% dead if one is dead.

      The evidence that has been shared by the LE is enough to presume that Ayla is no longer alive. Obviously it is what the LE believes and they hold even more evidence then has been released.

      Delete
    10. Anonymous 11:12 PM, Courts of law have found people guilty of murder in cases where no body has been found. Courts of law have declared people dead, when their bodies have not been found. One certainly can determine that someone is 100% dead without a body.

      Delete
    11. "Since you dont live with the DiPietros I'm going to have to say you have no idea what they do, have done , or are currently doing."

      Anonymous 5:12 PM, the same can be said for you. I assume you do not "live with the DiPietro family" either.

      So whatever you think or say is speculation, too. My speculation is from observation. My observations lead me to believe that the DiPietro's have no interest in finding Ayla, as they most likely, already know where she is.

      Delete
  24. Jeff...I really don't understand why you tap Chelsea Hoffman to be your sock puppet and report on Ayla. For those interested, here is Chelsea's promotion piece on her new newly released book: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QU16ZD_fqbM

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Death is pleasure?!" Porn?! She obviously takes a sick thrill in covering crimes and is using them to sell garbage to anyone who thinks violent crimes are sexy. Profiting from tragedy to peddle the problem and not solution is sick (I am OK with detectives making money, for example, because they are there to help solve cases, not exploit them for sick motives.)

      Delete
    2. Disgusting, isn't it? Why would Jeff align himself with CH? She has zero credibility, peddles smut, and can't write for shit. Ayla deserves better.

      Delete
    3. So Chelsea wrote a book profiling the most horrifying cases of sexual sadism in true crime history and I’m being raked over the coals and tortured by Anon Trolls. …seems fitting.

      Delete
  25. Ayla Reynolds
    Missing since: 2011

    Town: Waterville, Maine


    On December 17, 2011, Ayla Reynolds (DOB 4-4-2010) was reported missing from her Violette Avenue home by her father Justin DiPietro. Investigators have ruled out any possibility that Ayla left the house on her own or that she was abducted. Investigators discovered Ayla's blood in the basement of her home, and the three adults who were in the home at the time are withholding information. Police believe that Ayla is probably dead.

    Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit North, 36 Hospital Street, Augusta, Maine 04330 1-800-452-4664

    Contact the Maine State Police, Criminal Investigation Division with information regarding this investigation. You may also report information about this crime using the online Report a Crime form.

    http://www.maine.gov/tools/whatsnew/index.php?topic=state_police_unsolved&id=605022&v=Article-missing

    I'm not trying to be argumentative, but do want to point out LE has not always said "believe" or "opinion". Here, from their web site, LE has stated as a known that information is being withheld bt those who where present in the house when Ayla went missing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lee, Once again your missing the point.

      Let me speak slowly. It is not right for you or anyone to condemn innocent people.

      Delete
  26. Anon 12:36, Thank you for your attempted insult.

    I did not miss your point, but evidently you missed mine. I have not given a divergent view to your stated intent, just clarified an inaccuracy. The only thing you mentioned that LE has left as "believe" is that Ayla is dead.

    Good day.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is one of the most important statements " believe " because it leaves the possibility she may be alive. With that possibility there it leaves room for hope. LE is very careful in what they do say because there is a possibility they have drawn some wrong conclusions. I am not saying they have, or the percentages are high that they have. They could be dead on but I wouldn't want to call anyone guilty yet. I am not anon 12:36 so please don't think I am trying to insult your intelligence in anyway.

      Delete
    2. "No one has been eliminated as a suspect," McCausland told CNN. Police have been careful not to name anyone a suspect and have warned against speculation.

      http://www.cnn.com/2013/09/13/justice/maine-missing-toddler-ayla-reynolds/

      Delete
    3. warned against speculation.It doesn't say you can't accuse the whole family of being guilty of murder though.

      Delete
    4. ."It doesn't say you can't accuse the whole family of being guilty of murder though"

      ...along with friends of the family.....

      Why on earth would MSP warn people not to speculate on who is a suspect?

      Maybe because their speculations could "lead them down the wrong set of tracks". Maybe because innocent people could be ridiculed, defamed and harassed.

      Delete
    5. Agree A 1
      AnonymousJanuary 12, 2014 at 5:20 PM

      Delete
    6. You can talk until your blue in the face. There are people who will never get it. Even when you talk s l o w l y.

      If Ayla is alive - I certainly hope she never sees the posts of how people described her being beaten to death by her own father. Or how her Aunt is an addict who goes to the methadone clinic every day. Or how her grandmother sleeps with everyone and anyone who has any power in the state of Maine. Do you even hear yourself talk?

      People jumping to conclusions. People spreading lies and hate and discontent. How miserable your lives must be.

      If you focused all that hate on finding Ayla she may be home by now.



      Delete
    7. The things said about her maternal family are not very nice either.

      Delete
    8. Trista was also harrassed and called "murderer" and other names priro to the blood evidence release. So you see how people can be. They dont know what their talking about, they dont know the whole story. It works both ways.

      Delete
  27. M.M. says..
    ..Tudelas, Roberts Refuse to Review Evidence
    Justin has been friends with the Tudela family since childhood, and the Tudelas housed him and the rest of the DiPietros for two weeks after the DiPietro house was declared a crime scene. MSP told Trista that the Tudelas refused to look at the blood photos. The investigators did not explain why they sought to review the photos with the Tudelas

    ...I hope you are not stating this is a fact. You have absolutely no way of knowing if this is true or not. Unless of course you are the MSP, or a Tudela, or Courtney Roberts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You know the really crazy thing about all of this. People think they are helping to keep Ayla's name and face out there and they are not. It is all about the opinion they have that keeps this going. They talk about who they think is guilty and how everyone else is wrong.Jeff has turned this into a soap opera I think he wants to create the next reality television show. How sad no wonder people go into secret chat rooms.

      Delete
    2. A1 is your comment directed at me or Jeff? That is a snip from Jeff's "The Case for Ayla". It is stated directly above the snip with the link embedded.

      "Why was Heidi confident that police had no proof or evidence? Why, when police requested the Tudelas view the “proof” and “evidence” did they refuse to? From The Case For Ayla:"

      here's the link http://united4ayla.com/the-case-for-ayla/

      Delete
    3. M.M,

      My comment was directed at you, since you wrote the post that contained the snip.

      I know where the statement originated.

      I simply said, that I hoped you were not stating that it was fact. I should have added, because it was in the Case For Ayla.

      In rereading, I see you did use a question mark, after asking why, when the police requested the Tudela's view the proof and evidenece did they refuse to?

      Since you used a question mark, you must also have doubts whether it is true or not.
      So I guess that answers my concern.

      After rereading

      Delete
    4. A1 the post is made up of snips from an online news article and the Case for Ayla with several questions followed by question marks. We all have varied opinions and this was an opportunity to voice them, nothing more. As far as the Tudelas not viewing the evidence, that isn't intentionally stated as fact anymore than the trip to Portsmouth (which obscure confirmed) is. Your welcome to comment at U4A and share your opinion too.

      Delete
    5. anonymous 7:30 Pm, Jeff hasn't turned this into a soap opera, all the commenters have done that. Jeff is just merely a family member trying to find out what happened to his step granddaughter. I feel safe in saying his motivation has always been and continues to be, to find the truth. Others have turned him into some kind of monster, which I can't understand at all. Perhaps if I ask Beth Holloway, she might be able to tell me more about this type of behavior. She was demonized by most forum commenters just because she was relentless in trying to find her missing daughter.

      Jeff, keep doing what you do for Ayla. It doesn't matter what others think, at least you speak out for her, at least you try to do what you can for her.

      I can't say the same for the Dipietro family, they sit on their @sses and do nothing for Ayla.

      Delete
    6. A1, obviously it doesn't matter how anyone states anything. I can call anything I want a fact and so can you (and you have).

      Everything anyone writes on a blog is opinion, even if they include facts and fiction. One cannot tell others what to say, how to say or even what to think about it. Although, people love to try.

      I'll tell you want the facts are, the facts are what I believe the facts are, no matter who says them. If I believe them, they are facts to me and if I don't believe them, they aren't facts to me.

      Delete
    7. @ AnonymousJanuary 15, 2014 at 6:50 PM
      Glad to see he has you believing in his smoke and mirrors game. Hey Jeff you have another one on the line better set your hook.

      Delete
    8. @ AnonymousJanuary 15, 2014 at 7:00 PM
      Why are you threatened by what Jeff says?

      Delete
    9. @AnonymousJanuary 15, 2014 at 11:28 PM
      I don't feel threatened I just think he is a fake and a liar. That is just my opinion so I don't feel bad if you don't agree with it.You have a right to yours.

      Delete
  28. Portland not Portsmouth

    ReplyDelete
  29. Let me Speak slowly

    It was a comment spoken in the heat of the moment. I tend to talk down to people when I lose respect for them, especially when they continue to play the same old song and dance and put blinders on when they don’t want to admit someone can be right and they can be wrong.

    U4A used to be a respected blog. Recently they have let CRAZY people brag about illegally harassing people by email. They have let their blog be used for hate, spitefulness and lies. A walking advertisement for haters and crazies.

    It has calmed down some since the little problem they had with the web page. I hope they can get back on track. This should be about Ayla, not about working people up into a hateful frenzy against Justin and CO.

    The end.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Justice for Ayla used to be a respected blog. They now let crazy people in here shouting the innocence for a sickly little coward. The Coward cannot and will not speak for himself or AYLA! The hate and spitefulness and lies for Justin from this are dispicable! IMO Tori has gone down hill completely. Allowing the scum on her site! IMO AND I HAVE THE RIGHT TO MY OPINION!

      Delete
    2. You have a right Ahole 12:10 its just nobody gives a shit.

      Delete
    3. To anon 12:10 PM
      Tori always said and I think still would tell you, you are welcome here as long as you can be respectful in your speech to others. You can voice your opinion without name calling that is offensive to others.

      If it is no longer a respected blog it is people calling other people crazy, cowards, and yes A holes. Tori has a lot of things going on at the present time. Give her and others a little break please.

      Delete
    4. @ AnonymousJanuary 16, 2014 at 12:10 PM

      I think you will find it hard to sling mud at other people and keep your hands clean.

      Delete
    5. Wow! Now Dana B. Why, do tell, is your reprimand for Anon 12:10 Are you friends with Anon 12:53???? Don't single out Anon 12:10 --- Anon 12:53 is just as offensive! In fact, Anon at 8:00 is why 12:10 responded! So Dana B. , are so saying you are always respectful? You can jump off your horse anytime. I have seen different....

      Delete
    6. No reprimand for anyone I mentioned 12:53 s name calling as well. I just don't think anyone needs to trash Tori her blog or anyone else. I was just explaining my interpretation of what Tori has said in the past, and asked she be given some consideration. If I offended you or anyone else it wasn't intended.

      Delete
    7. Dana,
      Just wanted to say hi, and hope that you're doing well.

      Delete
    8. Hi A1 things are going great for me. Hope the gang is all doing well.

      Delete
    9. Dana...I too want to throw my voice in to say I'm wishing you well! Hope all is going splendid on the golf course! Best to you and your family, friend!

      Delete
    10. Glad to hear all is well Dana.

      The "gang" are all doing okay. We miss you though.
      Wish you would join the Chat. It is really a benefit. We look at several aspects of Ayla's case. Are able to express frustrations, without being ridiculed, with the benefit of not hurting others. Also, we are uplifting to one another. I've found it to be a big comfort at times.

      Please know you are missed Dana.

      Delete
    11. Hi Mckee good to hear from you golf is going great. A1 glad things are working so well with the discussions, I am trying to stay pretty low key and waiting for new developments.

      Delete
  30. JUSTIN, himself, has worked everyone into a hateful frenzy! He needs to start talking!
    Little Ayla needs to come home and justice needs to taken. Speak for Ayla, Justin!!
    This is about Ayla, You DO know something!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hate is something only one person is responsible for, and that is the hater it is a choice you make. I agree Justin knows something, that is it would do him no good to try to talk to you. You have made your mind up and nothing he says will change it.

      Delete
  31. I see it as I see it. I speak for Ayla. Hate? What about love of a little girl? Get off your high horse. This is MY opinion. I speak when I want to speak! I really could care less if he wants to talk to me----obviously he doesn't want to speak about Ayla to anyone. Hate? You speak of the Dipietro clan, Come on Justin-Speak for your little Girl!

    ReplyDelete
  32. Show us Justin that you don't HATE your own flesh and blood!! BLOOD? What about it Justin. Let's talk about the blood! To Anyone!

    ReplyDelete
  33. HATE is a pretty strong word 11:10 Anon! Hate? I hate the fact that Justin is such a sickly coward and women are his only supporters! Even Derrick doesn't speak for his bestest friend anymore! Cuz now Derrick is hiding, along with his mommy dearest! OOPS, probably here, but using Anon or another fake name!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Wow.. Crazies are out in force today.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I don't have time to be online 24/7. I also don't find bickering and insulting others including those involved conducive to finding Ayla. If I had something new to write about that wasn't rehashing the thousands of possibilities we have already discussed, I would write a blog post but sadly there is no info.

    Commenters here and at other blogs have both said nasty and hateful things. I am not going to spend time moderating comments because someone doesn't like what someone else has to say and vice versa. If this doesn't remedy itself pronto ( meaning be adults and have respectful discussion and stop with the nasty comments) I will just shut down the blog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Emotions are running high, still I don't see why everyone can't be civil. I do wish questions asked could be addressed instead of name calling and snarky remarks.

      One question I have for Phoebe is why did you lose a golden opportunity to call Trista out as a liar on the so-called Ayla blood evidence in your letter to the media?

      Phoebe was not shy about accusing Trista of hiding Ayla on TV. I would have thought her letter pleading for everyone to keep looking for Ayla would have been a golden opportunity for Phoebe to deny Trista's exaggerations or outright lies about what LE supposedly showed her and Alex and his mom.

      Phoebe could also have denied that Justin, and Elisha had withheld any information from the police.She could have strongly stated that all of the family have the told the truth and held back nothing and LE is completely wrong in their assessment of the three who were there when Ayla vanished.

      Instead, Phoebe's letter was a sort of pie-in-the-sky wishful thinking statement. Keep looking for an alive Ayla. She has big blue eyes which will help with her identification. She'll probably be found by a good Samaritan. I is up to all of us and LE to find her and bring her home.

      Adding to this directive, Phoebe could also have expressed some worry about Ayla's two years with a kidnapper. I would think that any grandmother would be worried about how Ayla was coping with any individual who would act so criminally as to steal a baby -- one who already had a turbulent history and now two recent changes of address...the first one to Justin and the second one to the kidnapper.

      Instead Phoebe only said, "Trista can say or do whatever she wants."
      Time to speak up, Phoebe, and Justin and Elisha (not counting on Courtney) show some spunk against LE and against all the accusations aimed in your direction because of your silence. Show some real concern for this little baby whose life was upturned a second time by a criminal abductor. You all must be intensely worried about Ayla's condition with this low-life. Why not show it? And if you truly believe that Trista is hiding Ayla, come out with it! Challenge LE to find that baby among Trista's relatives and friends!

      Delete
    2. Phoebe evidently believes Trista is hiding Ayla. As she said to Trista: "Tell us where she is!"

      I don't understand why no nonsense Phoebe isn't taking charge of finding Ayla as she took charge in taking custody of Ayla in the first place. Makes no sense to me. I can't figure it out.

      Delete
    3. Anon 5:32 AM, it's easy, Phoebe knows what happened to Ayla and where she is. She screamed at Trista because she HATES her. It's why she orchestrated the taking of Ayla. Pure evil.

      Delete
    4. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  36. What happened to the blog "For Ayla?" The posts are gone.

    http://forayla.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  37. I hesitate to post this but here goes nothing.
    At one point in this nightmare of responses someone said that it was irresponsible of Trista to have left Ayla in the care of her father when she went into rehab. I am assuming you are referring to Justin as the father Trista left Ayla with. I would like to address this misinformation.
    1) It has been reported by numerous news outlets that Trista left Ayla in the care of Ayla's maternal grandfather and a maternal aunt.
    2) It was Ms. Small, a supervisor at CPS [and a relative of the DiPetros according to the BDN article I read] who went outside the bounds of her position and removed Ayla from the home of her maternal relatives and placed her in the home Justin shared with his mother.
    3) the DiPetro family has a CPS history - the Reynold's family does not. Again, this comes from what the reporters for the BND and KJ have uncovered in their investigation into facts pertaining to the families involved in this case.
    I get it that many of the people in this comments section know many of the people involved personally with this case so it is easy for tempers to get flared. In keeping with the tone the blog owner usually tries to set I just want to say that I am only pointing out reported facts from reputable news sources that have done the investigative leg work to bring out the details in this case. My interest purely lies in there being some form of justice for whatever has happened to sweet little Ayla. If she is deceased may she rest in peace and if she is out there being held captive may she be found and returned to her family soon.

    ReplyDelete