I have read many things over the past year and a half about Ayla Reynolds. There are facts, theories, speculation, and downright lies all over the internet involving this case. Some people believe Ayla is alive and well somewhere, while others believe Ayla’s own family killed her, whether by accident or on purpose, and have disposed of Ayla as if she were garbage. Many hurtful accusations and speculation have been leveled against both sides of Ayla’s family.
Personally, I believe that there was a kidnapping of sorts. My theory involves both parents of this beautiful little girl. I know neither side of the family personally, nor do I know any extension of the families, (i.e. Heidi, Angela, Jeff, Tori, John P, etc), so I have no stake in the outcome of this case. My theory takes all “evidence” into account and, I feel, at the very least, is a possibility. The ID channel documentaries show that anything is possible in disappearances, murders, etc.
I believe that on the night of December 17, 2011, Ayla Reynolds was removed from her Grandmother’s home by her own family. I believe that kadoe’s friend/relative’s account of having seen someone in the Dipietro’s neighborhood early that morning happened and was the exchange of Ayla. I believe that Trista had a rendezvous with Justin at some point (possibly the 15th or 16th) where the 2 of them fought about custody of Ayla after a sexual encounter (which left her DNA/blood on Justin’s sheets). I feel this fight is what precipitated Ayla’s“disappearance”.
I believe that a member or a couple of members of Justin’s or Trista’s family (maybe even a member of each side) either witnessed or was informed of the fight between Trista and Justin and decided to take matters into their own hands. A plot was hatched to remove Ayla from these 2 destructive parents and give her to someone that could take proper care of her without all the drama and fighting.
I believe that possibly Elisha and Phoebe or Phoebe and a member of Trista’s family arranged for a new “family” for Ayla. I think this is where kadoe’s story comes into play. The witness stated a person they thought was Phoebe met with a group of people and handed over a very much alive child very early on the morning of Ayla’s disappearance. I feel as though it may have been done to give Ayla the best, as these family members knew that neither Trista nor Justin had Ayla’s best interest at heart and these family members couldn’t, for whatever reason, take care of Ayla themselves.
I believe the luminol showed “cleanup” of a fecal accident, a pee accident or a puke accident. There were rumored to be 4 small dots of blood shown in a photo, those could have been a small cut. The cleanup of feces, pee or puke accident would show DNA and glow withluminol if cleaned with bleach and an accident with something like that would seem alarming if thought to be blood.
I think this theory is plausible. It explains why Justin made the comment “you aren’t her parent”. I believe this is possible, maybe not probable, but definitely possible.